MoneyNeverSleeps
MoneyNeverSleeps
Sharp riffs, big ideas and real insights from smart people - all in under 15 minutes.

Hosted by early-stage investor Pete Townsend with the people rebuilding money, markets, and the internet from the ground up.
Nov. 18, 2022

199: Money Talks #57: FTX WTF | Musk Monetizing Twitter | UK Tech Nation Revolts | Big Tech vs. Irish Startups

199: Money Talks #57: FTX WTF | Musk Monetizing Twitter | UK Tech Nation Revolts | Big Tech vs. Irish Startups
199: Money Talks #57: FTX WTF | Musk Monetizing Twitter | UK Tech Nation Revolts | Big Tech vs. Irish Startups
MoneyNeverSleeps
199: Money Talks #57: FTX WTF | Musk Monetizing Twitter | UK Tech Nation Revolts | Big Tech vs. Irish Startups

This week, Eoin and Pete take the inevitable plunge into what to make of the FTX mess and then resurface with some of the scenarios unfolding on what Elon Musk has in mind for the 250 million daily active users of Twitter.  The guys also look at the hubbub around the control of Tech Nation in the UK, a Digital Dollar pilot in the US, and how the Big Tech layoffs in Ireland may be short-term pain but long-term gain.

This episode of MoneyNeverSleeps is sponsored by SecuriCentrix. SecuriCentrix is a trusted cyber security company with offices in Dublin, Cape Town and London. SecuriCentrix provides expert advisory services, primarily in the finance and fintech industries, with tailored security solutions to fit your specific needs and regulatory challenges.

STORIES COVERED

The Casino and the Genie (Mario Gabriele, The Generalist newsletter, 13-Nov-22, h/t Packy McCormick)

5 More Disturbing Revelations About Sam Bankman-Fried (NY Magazine, 14-Nov-22)

Elon Musk details his vision for a Twitter payments system (TechCrunch, 9-Nov-22)

Startup founders go to war with UK government over its moves to appoint bank into key ecosystem role (TechCrunch, 15-Nov-22)

Global Banks Partner With New York Fed for 12-Week Digital Dollar Pilot (Watcher Guru, 12-Nov-22),

‘I’m doing this 26 years and I’ve never seen anything like it’: Laid-off tech staff hunt for new work (Business Post (paywall), 12-Nov-22)

LINKS

Leave a review and subscribe on Apple Podcasts | Spotify

Check out our MoneyNeverSleeps website and email us at info@moneyneversleeps.ie

Follow us on Twitter: MoneyNeverSleeps | Eoin Fitzgerald | Pete Townsend

--- Support this podcast: https://anchor.fm/moneyneversleeps/support

0:11 Hey there, I'm Pete Townsend, and this is money, never sleeps. We look inside the minds of entrepreneurs, and at the crossover of startups, Enterprise Finance, technology and Life. As We Know It, This episode of money. Never sleeps is sponsored by security. Centrex security Centrex is a trusted cyber security company. With offices. In Dublin, Cape Town in London, security, Centrex provides expert advice. Zuri Services primarily in the finance and fin Tech Industries with tailored Security Solutions to fit your specific needs and Regulatory challenges in this episode on Fitzgerald. And I take the inevitable plunge into what to make of the ft x mess. And then we resurfaced with some of the scenarios unfolding on what Elon Musk has in mind for the 250 million daily active users of Twitter. We also look at the hubbub around the control of tech nation in the UK, a digital dollar pilot in the US and how the big Tech layoffs and Ireland may be short-term pain but long-term gain.

1:03 All right here on money, never sleeps. Heyo and heard you're sick, boy. I hope a piece. Yeah, vomiting bug in my house all week. It's been a disaster. That sucks. Sorry to hear that. Nobody's too bad. It's just you can't do anything when people are getting sick around you. Yeah, yeah. Constant. I need a new tell. I need a new change of clothes. I need a new. Yeah. And demanda washing of had to do in the meantime as well. Yeah. Yeah. Sounds a lot. Like what's going on in the crypto markets, everyone puking. Exactly. So it's not just you brother or your, and your and your kids contagion effect, from one of us, spread to the rest. Let's count this moment in history, folks. It's the Fitzgerald, Family that's attributable for everything that's happening right now. Oh, I wouldn't wish that upon anybody, but listen, it's been a nut.

2:05 So, 10 days, obviously, we're Recorded last week's episode. When all of this was unfolding and I did the emergency brake, and on Friday morning is, the editing was going on and gave it a little bit of a rant. They're just some of my own personal feelings, but this is just been crazy. It's moving faster every single day, with everything, that's coming to light, isn't it? Yeah, Joe, I saw and, I can't remember who to attribute it, but I saw a very good artist, comment on Twitter and someone just said, you know, a lot of the madness around f. Dax was already public by gets, you know, it's a bit Rich, after the fact, coming back and say no, they did this and they did this and this are the operated at most of the stuff was already known, you know, whatever about moving money and customer funds. But like how they run the business was known to everybody. Yeah, yeah, this was, this was out there. I've been seeing emails, you know, I don't know how true this stuff is.

2:59 Obviously it's if it's on Twitter, has to be true, right? You Lon so it's but things like meth amphetamines and you SPF giving instructions and orientation presentations on how to use methamphetamines to be more efficient, and more have to accelerate your work practices, right? I'm like, okay, that's but who knows, who knows? But listen, I think the one, the one, the one thing that I kind of came up with out of nowhere, yesterday was SPF right now, is reminding me of that evil Biff Tannen in Back to the Future 2. Okay. Where He what happened was that not to ruin the movie? I mean, it's like, I don't know, 30 years old now, it's going to care, but in Back to the Future Biff is introduced in 1985. Is a middle-aged man who pushes around Marty's father George and then when Marty goes back to the 1955, he's a high school bully who makes fun of George and harasses Marty's mother Lorraine.

3:58 But then when Marty and Doc Brown, travel to the future of 2015, at Back to the Future Part 2, they meet this angry. 78 year old Biff Tannen and he overhears Marty's plan to use a 2015 Sports almanach to go back in time and make money in the 80s, right? So because they did that in the year 2015 Biff goes back steals the DeLorean goes back to himself in 1955 and gives himself this Sports Almanac and he's got all the results for the next. I don't know. Oh, 60 years or whatever, what's happening in the world. And he comes a millionaire, and you end up in this very evil version of Hill Valley, which is a town that this all takes place in were Biff is like mayor.

4:47 He owns Casino, he runs it. He's stolen for the rain and so on and so forth. And then through the rest of Back to the Future, they go back and they eradicate all that. So, like what SBF has done and it's, you know, it's not him alone. And there's been a gaggle of individuals around him and both that were part of FDX and external to FTX and Alameda that have promoted this and have allowed it to happen, allowed it to continue and allowed. This this snowball to go downhill that are now, you know, these, I don't know, evil co-conspirators that and we just need to go find whenever that Sportsbook was handed over to SPF and get rid of that. Alternate reality.

5:28 That feels like we're in right now where SB F stands for scammy. Biff Tannen exactly. So just to give a bit of a rundown here, the uninitiated. So what happened was that Sam set up Alameda, research it Squad, trading firm / hedge fund back in 2017 and they became known for their super aggressive strategies and Caroline Ellison was implanted as CEO. I don't know if that was at the beginning or sometime during the run-up between 2017 and now, but it she was and well, I think gone now obviously the CEO. So Sam. Then set up the FTX crypto Exchange in 2019 with the tagline Designed by Traders for Traders, which sounds a hell of a lot like Enron.

6:11 And now, John, Jay re the second or third, well, what are you, whatever, he is his, he's the new FTX CEO and he helped wind down and Ron, so then FTX built up, billions of deposits and crypto on their exchange and going against our terms and conditions. They decided to reuse those deposits as they. Please not sure when they started doing that might have been back around the time of Voyager, and three hours capital and Tara Luna happening. And basically what it means is that you're holding Things tab in your in your FTX app is just a bunch of iou's so they're not crypto asset secure digitally in your own wallet. So one of the ways they reused your assets and probably the biggest way is that they loaned your assets to Alameda research, the super aggressive Quan trading firm, / hedge fund also owned by SBF to leverage their trading with borrowed assets, But the loans from FDX to Alameda needed to be collateralized. So, what did Alameda use for collateral? Well, they had bought a bunch of the FTX tokens called ftt that FDX had created is basically these loyalty points. The more you hold the cheap, your trading Alameda held over two billion dollars on their balance sheet of ftt that they used as collateral for the, basically the customer deposits, or what were in effect customer deposits that At Alameda borrowed from FTX all under the watch of sandbank been freed. So this token ftt was basically created out of thin air and then staple on top of the exchange and they help to keep the price of float of ftt.

7:44 With one Alameda is Market making the token and to FTX using the profits that they earned on the exchange with transaction fees to buy ftt on the open market. But when when CZ from Finance, who also held a huge amount of Ft Tito, Ins over 500 million dollars worth of them announce that he's liquidating. People run for the doors and they dumped ftt, the ftt token, drop 90% Alameda is collateral goes through the floor and they can't repay the loans back to FTX and then FDX can't meet customer withdrawals. So you file for chapter 11 bankruptcy. Yep, that's it. It's I feel like we've been on such a wonderful path with crypto even with Tara Luna Three arrows, Capital Voyager, this is now for bad things, don't happen in threes, they happen in fours. This is the fourth crypto winter as well that all this work that we've been doing.

8:43 It's not there's an SPF and there's a ft x and Alameda research House of Cards but there's you know, the whole digital asset. March the crypto March, the web three progress that we've made over the last 10, 12 years, all of that is still critically important, all of that will still Continue. Its that. We've just got this big black mark, that is called SPF on what's happened. And we've talked about and plenty of times and talked about him on. This podcast is positive. How could he could be the guy, you know, he was gonna vote for lobbying regulators and stuff like that. And go go doing it. What it look appeared to be in the right way. But again, we're not looking too much under the hood. No, never snowed. We, we haven't been an end and shout out to Paki McCormick because in his not boring newsletter, this This week. The kind of said, listen, I don't want to write too much about this because so much has been said already, but he did point to what he thought was the best summation, not summation of the events that happen, but kind of, of the perspectives around the world right now on, what's going on with all this. And that was from Mario, Gabrielle the generalist newsletter from the 13th and November that he pointed to. And in this post and the generalist Mario, gave this whole view into what he called the casino and the Jeanne, I won't get into the casino description. I think we know what that is when it comes to crypto. There's a lot of gambling going on and uninformed trading going on that is just obviously like ambling, but he was drawing this analogy to a genie turning up

10:14 with 10 chocolates and saying, one of them will make you rich Beyond Your Wildest Dreams. The other nine are poisonous. So what he's going to do, we're going to pick one. Well start to dig into your research blah blah, I'll let our listeners read the post. I'm not going to give a full rundown of it but it gets to the end of Of it, and he's kind of like, you know, doing this analogy around chocolate and crypto. He said, I think there's something to this chocolate. I've thought about it a lot, I've studied and I believe it could be something remarkable. Something miraculous he said, this is why I am still long crypto despite its many flaws. I believe it has miraculous potential to improve our world self Sovereign money, smart contracts, and digital property rights or radical revolutionary ideas that we are in the early Innings of understanding.

10:56 And applying in a matter of decades, we may look back on the state's rigid Stranglehold on money as Quirky artifact in obvious. Over each decentralized Finance has its own quirks but is held up well by comparison showing that code is often less corruptible than people. We may see it blue more fully in the coming years, right? So you know really good kind of you know view into all of this. I've been saying to everybody. It's a massive massive speed bump but it's not a stop sign. Anyone, that is selling to financial institutions and trying to enable financial institutions in their customer base. Has to connect into defy Connect into crypto. There is some analysis of personalities making decisions that we need to dig into a lot more and say, how can we unlock some of these conversations even in the face of what's happening right now to show? Listen, that's be F and F DX are not crypto. They are a nasty combination of multi Fiat crypto, eMoney wallet type of thing following no rules, right? Because I think what came out was that they held they held zero Bitcoin A major fds for a major crypto exchange to hold, no Bitcoin crazy that because they, all they had, was Bitcoins a nominated liabilities because they had loaned it all out. Okay, against the terms and conditions of the Ft x.com website, your assets will not be

12:26 reused. So it's it's a nasty turn of events. Yeah. And one that I think is going to have a lot more implications. You know, Gary Gensler has been coming out, you know, even before this happened and said, you know, with his view on that most crypto are securities, most crypto assets are securities. As it turns out, there's a connection between Gary Gensler and MIT going back to 2019, 2018. I met Gary Gensler in Dublin, when he was speaking at a educational event. When he was teaching a blockchain course at MIT. Cool and he was involved, I think he was working Working in the department of it was some economics department. And the head of that economics Department was the father of Caroline Ellison, who was ahead of Alameda research, which Sam Bank been freed also owned.

13:21 So there's some voices going around in d.c. right now that are suggesting that there's going to be some type of investigation here as to what Gary Gensler is, involvement might have been allegedly, right? I'm not going to, you know, You can't, what do we always say? You can't make this stuff up, right? Yeah, that's it. I look I saw I saw it interesting. Just told in the end, I subscribe to net interest which is a newsletter by guy named Mark Rubenstein and he was just talking to they point. He was making is that you know Banks go bust more often than we think or we might not even realize in like in the five years from 2016 to 2020 in the u.s. 21 Banks went bankrupt.

14:02 You know, the most recent one is October 2020, which was a lie. Nina State Bank in Kansas and I suppose you know there's just a regular kind of failures in banking in the US as well as the different. The point he was making here was even in that example of the one in Kansas. You know that wasn't a large Bank as such but The Regulators went in over the weekend on a fried Bank closed. Its doors on a Friday. Regulators went in over the weekend transferred. All the assets and liabilities to a different bank which is like 60 miles away or whatever. And then a Monday morning customers woke up to say that there were customers of a new bank, all dirt, all Dyrdek. As it were covert under a depository at deposit interest scheme and it all worked out for everybody.

14:43 And like obviously we've seen that in a larger scale here and he was but suppose you know making the direct comparison to that's the difference for all the bad and for all that you know the selling on your own crypto and not being regulated and everything. The fact is people can be people's money is safe on the other hand. Yep, you know, or those mechanisms to try protect customers and people's money. Jesus Christ. You know, the the I had and of course, I could look at this, you know, quarterback Monday Morning Quarterback. Hindsight is 20/20, I had opened in FTX account at some point last year and just so I could buy the audio token, which is the token that is part of the whole Audience Network, its digital music and I set up the account I sent some, I might have sent some eith over and exchange the E3 for audio and then I let it sit there for about a week and then I move the audio out of FTX to my metal mask account and that's it.

15:47 So, I still have that FTX app on my phone. I actually just deleted it this morning. So I know that people were saying delete it right away over the weekend. The last few days. It may contain malware. Now that FDX has been hacked so, But the I made that move but to your point a lot of people didn't, I don't know what happened to Tom Brady, right. He had a lot of his savings, I think not a lot of his savings but he had considerable amount of value. It probably was sort of deep relationship with them sponsorship and everything. Yeah I do. Anything of the kind of last note commented make may be honored would be. I wonder. Will this be a kind of Tara knows moment for the industry. You know, it's only now really that you're seeing kind of Biotech Solutions being brought back to Market, you know, it set it back nearly Ten years in terms of wider spread adoption or customer-facing sort of stuff.

16:36 And I just wonder will it have that effect? Because like I said my anything else, it is really embarrassed. A lot of investors. Big-time big-time who said, listen, I don't know why I feel this but it's like I'm talking to the world's first trillionaire this. What one investor said? Yeah, what was that? Stupid one, where they were interviewing him about giving him money and he was playing League of Legends at the same time? Oh yeah, this was great. Yeah, honestly, no hyper. Smart people do that. They can listen in and have an intelligent conversation like that. Well, imagining that they're sitting in a boardroom and they're looking up with the walls and seeing monkeys jumping around that actually happened to me. Once I wasn't the guy seeing imaginary monkeys but someone else in the in a boardroom with me say that to me. So what are you thinking at?

17:21 He's like, oh kind of bored. I'm imagining there's monkeys jumping around up there and this was a hyper intelligent very smart person. Also in Quant trading like Sam. So there are people like that out there. So instead of seeing monkeys jumping around and you play League of Legends which you know close enough right, let me take a minute to tell you more about our sponsors security Centric. Strives to be the trusted partner that secures your information assets deemed critical for your business security. Centrex also delivers the highest level of security expertise and support to their It even further security, Centrex provides independent cyber security assessments and advisory against best, practice industry, standards and compliance Frameworks working as an extension of your team security.

18:13 Centrex helps you recognize and Control Data risks to your business by understanding your level of risk. In short security, Centrex provides many solution offerings from assessment and advisory managed Security, Services, cloud and infrastructure, validation vulnerability, management and testing. Ting and payment security. Get in touch with a team at security. Centrex.com to learn more or email info at security. Centrex.com, that's SEC. You Ric, entr I x.com. One to watch out of all of this is easy, the CEO of finance and he's done a number of things in in spfs apology.

19:00 Tweet, he points to what he calls a sparring partner as in. Well, played I won't get into the whole debacle of what happened over last weekend or over last week between CZ from finance and SPF. But by Nance have now set up, this kind of Recovery Fund for those. That were wiped out or significantly damaged, you're hurt by what happened with FTX. They are kind of mopping up right now and, you know, there's it's going to be interesting to see how, how, by Nance do out of all of this. And I still think it's so funny to things to close on this. All of the folks who don't say the word Finance, they say the word Finance. How do you say it Finance?

19:47 Yeah, you know I hear them actually. Ali refer to finance as banants and there's a certain demographic of usually Bros from West Coast or east coast well, educated in finance, I'm gonna say Finance, not finance, that called Finance Finance. So look out for those folks. Once you see more and more people referring to finances banants, you know that, okay? They've really one coming out of this whole FTX drama. The last thing I'll say about This today is shout out to bury Skinner who in one of our signal channels. Talking about all this to SBF as scam bankrupt fraud and a penniless itinerant and we'll leave it that. I don't think he's that penniless anyway. Anyway, moving on, moving along to Back to the Future. All right, Elon Musk with Twitter, this just clicked. When you sent it to me.

20:48 He didn't actually buy Twitter because he loves social media, he bought a big, Global hyperactive audience, didn't he? Yeah. And going back to the future with what he tried to do with x.com back in the 90s that became PayPal. But that just became totally different than I think. What is perhaps, what his original Vision was? And now looking at well, I've got a massive, huge Global audience here. I've got tons of millions of users. Let's look at how we might be able. Well to leverage that into what his original x.com version was of being this WeChat like super app and that's where we chat started. It's in the name, it's chat and Twitter. What do you do?

21:30 You chat sort of were, you know, you troll, you comment, you profess you pronounce, you distribute, whatever you want to do. That was that that looks really interesting. You want to talk us through what's going on with him? Detailing his vision for a Twitter payment system? Yeah, yes. So I saw this on a few sites French times comment on it and TechCrunch actually, which is the one I was referring to. But yeah, I believe he applied for a license broader kind of financial services, but when you're in payments initially and detailed it to the staff and there were some questions around loans and he talked about, you know, you didn't certainly was going to leave out the opportunity to provide a key, kind of financial So Services product But ultimately I think he was talking about providing some sort of access to high yield deposits and payments within Twitter.

22:19 And I think he's ultimately it's like we talked about with odor. Is it? You know, if you have that captive audience, how do you monetize them by providing fairly easy to roll out Financial Services products? Payments being the first one within the app payments seems like a no-brainer especially when you have people having to start paying for the verification. They've already got their card details. Open everything. Now you can start paying different kind of Partners a different people that you're following or whatever subscriptions, you can see all that kind of been moved inside. So even like we reference for five people. Now, that of newsletters that we subscribe to some of those offer page options, I'd say there's no reason why you wouldn't see those people start to put two subscription links and everything within Twitter so that you can pay in Twitter. So it makes a lot of sense when you have Dash much of a captive audience I suppose, the challenge is that it doesn't appear from the outside that he's doing a good job of Twitter in the First instance.

23:09 Anyway, yeah, boss, anyone that has a massive following on Twitter is not going to be in a mad rush to leave it. So you know, he probably has plenty of time and kind of Goodwill to get things right and it makes total sense. Why wouldn't you try do it? If it's not going to be a huge Endeavor to start bringing in some payments and some other Solutions in the same way we've seen in other kind of, you know, Square I suppose is one and block that we've talked about it, considerably away with cash app, you know, that's probably The model is looking at, it's just that they've had 10 years. Ahead of them. Yeah. So yeah II it's fascinating because the, this is all, you know, rolling into so many different directions that this could all go with Twitter. And I'm just sitting here thinking about how Twitter works today.

24:01 So much noise out there but then a, you know, at least 10% of it is genuine helpful thoughts that I use and leverage in what I do every day from an investment perspective. Yeah. So what I pay for it? Yeah I probably would because I still find myself. Hey I heard someone talking about a tweet on a podcast. I want to go find that tweet because I know if I look further down in the thread there's going to be a helpful snippet that's going to get me to think about something a little bit differently and give me some more conviction in a certain area, right? So if Twitter were to expand into some type of financial account Would it be something that I would feel comfortable using?

24:44 Well, not if it was just some, you know, insecure message board, but if it were, you know, intended to become an ecosystem. And, yeah, this could go in a lot of different ways, but, yeah, sorry. And I see just the beginning, I found some bit more detail out here is talking about initially monetizing content creation. So like that. If you want to pay for specific content that you've In from packing McCormick, for example, but more as a one-off, you know, low value, high volume, types of payments. That's what they're targeting initially, which, you know, they'll take a quarter of and it's both the article here, this is a Forbes article that what they're saying is the challenge with that around, economics will be that, you know, they're dead.

25:28 He's then responsible for the in-app payment on a particular platforms. Anyway. So for example, the IOS app would have to pay a 30 percent fee. So Twitter would have to add a fee on top of that. So the economics will be very tough on it. However, you know, it's potentially peer-to-peer transfers vertical be considerable value. And that's what he talks about in a separate conversation. You talking about if you've got a balance on your account, you want to send money to it, someone else within Twitter. So you could see in a situation where we would, you know, load up our Twitter wallet and every so often you see a piece of content that you want to access or purchase and that's it, you just purchase it as a one-off.

26:10 And by sending Ash within the app to somebody you can see huge potential market and not, you know what I'm thinking. Now like back the problem, the 90s with all this is that the internet wasn't designed and they base layers of technology in this and the coding software what was not developed for payments and what we've done over the last 25 years is really just, you know, put Band-Aids and and bubblegum on top of the whole thing too. Be able to support payments. Now, look at things. Now in the year 2022 is a social media system. Really the social media platform really safe secure engineered for all this wood, Facebook move to Facebook, pay. I'm not sure how much of that has taken off and it's just because people aren't used to engaging in everyday spending and decisions based upon what's going on on their Facebook account, right.

27:14 But but Twitter's different to an extent, could a critical mass of Twitter users who are monetizing content and at critical mass of Twitter users who are want to consume that content, will they would there be enough value Changing Hands in either Fiat or crypto? Here because that is a real possibility. Will it be enough of a critical mass to move in the direction of Twitter? Becoming the original x.com vision? And that he did just buy a massive Global audience for what our don't like anyone to be. What it would be Elon Musk probably the better comparison here will be YouTube.

27:58 Ultimately look makes a majority of its revenue from. Yeah, it's bullsh. You know, obviously feels I'd Siddharth with content. So I don't think he's looking to turn this into a, you know, it's entirely funded by content creation, but the majority of people on Twitter with large followings, are creating content of some kind. So, you know, being able to replace some of that revenue is lost from advertising by bringing in subscriptions or payments or whatever, seems to be a good move. Given the types of users that are on Twitter and what they're using it for. Yeah. Yeah, I'd say it's the audience of Twitter.

28:39 The user base. Twitter is big enough where they're going to spend a boatload on trying to build this that they should, at least have break. Even with all the layoffs that Twitter has been doing in the manner in which Elon Musk he's communicating that which is pretty crappy. Look that payments, First Step, you know, if he can get payments right on it and get people using it, even if that, just breaks even then, obviously being able Ball to roll out. Whether it's short small loans, you know, small dollar loans. Whatever it is you know, do following along with cash. What? Cash app is doing? Yeah, you know. It's great potential there then. Yeah. Yeah. Well, we'll see where he ends up with this. It's way too late.

29:21 But it was like I said, it was, you know, you start thinking about these things differently. When while someone like going Fitzgerald, send you a post and says this is more than just what it looks like. Yeah, absolutely definitely. So thank you. Next thing you wanted to look at were this startup Founders in the UK going to war with the UK government, over its moves to a point eight? Yes, into this key ecosystem role right? Which is okay, let's appoint Barclays to run Tech nation in the UK which is kind of the startup policy and promotion, arm of the UK startup industry more or less.

30:03 So you Katie Tech startup tech industry which just doesn't feel right A Bank kind of taking that over. Where did this one come from again? This is one on TechCrunch to, but I saw this a couple weeks back. So it was for technician was to previous government. Bodies was formed in 2019 supporting about 4,000. UK companies, get 75 percent of its revenue from government grants. So, effectively a government agency, or semi state, or whatever acquaintance as it's before going. Yeah, quasi NGO across, and it went out to Tender and Barclays, got awarded the contract and like I remember seeing it and thinking well that just, you know, that Joe, we talked about this version of this a few weeks ago when we talked about, oh God. What was that Finn tank utilities like? Yes, fintech utilities.

30:51 Exactly. And we said is it right? That a valuable resource in the industry would be acquired or majority owned by one particular player. And we were of in agreement that? No and then you have an important resource. Is to an industry being owned by one particular player owned by one particular player. Like, you can't argue that in any way that there's going to be, you know, that everyone's going to be treated fairly or it would appear to be treated. Fairly like, you know, you're talking about some of the best and brightest companies potentially coming out of the UK here and Barclays have an inside track on it. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I mean, just a parallel to what's going on in Ireland. I mean, you know, the the national digital Research Center which was not quite Tech Nation but at least it was A government entity that was helping to promote sponsor investment into startups and research alongside it was being run by someone called digital Hub, I think. And then the the contract went up for tender and Dogpatch Labs one it and just had a big Vision doing wrong patch Labs doing this versus say, Bank of Ireland. Jesus, that would be night and day, right? So there is it just it doesn't feel right and and you know Barclays have done a number of things over the years with startup ecosystems.

32:03 And that have been incredibly helpful, you know, they salute me, it's not, it's not a slight or knock on Barclays, like, you know, we both said, involved in stuff to be Dune UK, they're incredibly good at us. It's just that the, I don't think you can allow a situation where something that's that important to the industry can be owned by one player at the detriment of others. So I think what happened here was 60 kind of co-signature, he's, you know, cofounders of wise and things like that. All signed up to a letter saying that they thought But they are what they say that this should be, the government should be funding this and it should stay like, that should be grounded in the startup ecosystem and local Easton system, not looking to write on. Its coattails is what they said. Another.

32:45 Yes. I just thought like that look. We were both well, a verse on what goes on in the industry here and how that helps and supports. And that just thought it was an interesting kind of comparison to what goes on here. Yeah, definitely, definitely jumping across the Atlantic to the United States of America. We have a announcement that US banks are launching a digital asset settlement platform proof and alongside that that story that you shared, which I think is the reference to the same thing, Global Banks partner with New York fed for 12-week digital dollar pilot, right? So just thought it was interesting context to everything else that's going on in the Crypt was base. Yeah, yeah, totally. And it's kind of like saying, well, you know, let's see if we can leverage some of this technology to introduce to the traditional Financial infrastructure.

33:32 Are some of the benefits of blockchain Technology. Now, there's a story that's been going on since 2014 2015 and in reality what it is, is that any technology? Whatever it is, if you want a big bunch of banks to adopt new technology and do something together, that's going to take a heck of a long time. So there's been a initiative on this side of the pond in Europe for well, back since 2015, when I first saw it coming out, it was Universal set. And Coin. And I forget that the original name of the player who was promoting this project, but they're now called finality, and they have become very institutional and it was the same thing that is being proposed here in the US and where I think it's being, you know, a regulated liability Network.

34:23 So to be able to have wholesale or Central Bank money, moving around between banks in a tokenize form which is great but this is kind of a precursor To Central Bank, digital currency or one of the elements of parts of a framework that you would need to have in place for Central Bank, digital currency to work and Central Bank, digital currency to me is way too much of a government looking over my shoulder in terms of what I'm doing with that money, right? So what it is it was you know some of the names that are in here in the other story on fenestra were bny. Mellon HSBC PNC, TD Bank, truest and US Bank are all participating in the experiment which critical were dotted with the technology provided by settle which tried to do something on this side of the pond settle with a few different directions and digital asset, which have been working on replacing the Australian stock exchange system with blockchain technology for the last five or six years.

35:19 And it keeps getting delayed and delayed and delayed again. Probably more indicative of Bank adoption of new technology and financial infrastructure. Provider adoption of new technology and also powered by a WS no-brainer, right? So this I think, Right. Sentiment, in terms of hay, in the face of what's going on with crypto and FDX, and finance and everything happening and all the drama there. What is can we point to a use case? That is going to actually be helpful? Absolutely. You know, we've been pointing this for years. It's just it's going to take an awful long time for The Banks of sort this out. And the failings of FDX, I'm gonna go out on a limb.

36:02 It had zero to do with blockchain technology itself, Badasses. Right. That is where we stand one last thing. I wanted to mention. Obviously, the situation here in Ireland were tons of people are being laid off across meta Twitter stri stripe. And this was an article in the Sunday business post or sorry, an article in the business post, only reason that I have access to business post is that I started paying for a subscription. When Charlie Taylor moved over there, Shadowcat Charlie Taylor Same. Big found it. Charlie. Yeah, definitely. And that there's lots of people, obviously, now on the job hunt, and that, this has happened over the last few weeks, but they're being scooped up right now. For a long time people, they all the, the financial services, the International Financial Services Center in Ireland, which is a huge success story in the 80's 90's and 2000's, but then kind of Technology, caught up with things, but the financial services industry, Did not and people like, well, if I want to do something new and Innovative, I'm gonna go work for one of these big Tech firms and now they're all laying them off. So hopefully there's one that influx of talent back into the financial services firms to get them to actually embrace digital Technologies in a serious matter. In the what we call the fund Services industry. The second impact hopefully is that they go in startups and then you've got people that are coming out with some Bank manatees and we bring that into

37:34 the startup ecosystem. Which would just be phenomenal. Obviously, people need to take risks in order to do that with their livelihoods, but this great supports out there now even better than the ones before and to praise our, unless our new precede fund, you know, that's 100K potentially to start something, which is far better for the markets. Very receptive. Very well received in the market, things like that. So hopefully we get more great startups out of it. Absolutely. And the, the article referenced Brian Caulfield and you know, he said I would hope that a lot of these people will end up in our own Tech sector, maybe even consider starting their own Businesses right? Shout out to Brian's been a stalwart of the the tech startup scene over the last 20 years here in Ireland. So all good. So you know obviously job loss is suck.

38:17 Yep. But it looks like it cause it feels like the job market is buoyant enough here and talking to some of our crew to friends who have commented. The same thing that the hiring going on right now is still just incredible. So yeah, you know, good luck to everybody and if anybody wants to bounce a start-up Idea off of me in web form a blockchain do Reach Out reach out and get in touch. Absolutely. I know Dave Cunningham offered the same thing and shout out to Dave, it's good friend and that, you know, we're here to help. So let's do it. Excellent. Alright. Well, thank you, pal, pleasure, as always, buddy, you hang in there with the vomiting bug and you know, keep that under control.

38:58 Yeah, taking it back to eating normally, I'd be happy. Thank you. Adios take it easy. That does it for this week folks, you can learn more about the stories we covered in the show notes on our website money, never sleeps. That IE also, thanks to Conan Brophy from creates, on for mixing and editing this episode, Conan is an excellent media ban to get in touch with when you're thinking about launching your own podcast. As for me, I'm an early stage, startup investor focused on where fintech meets crypto and crypto meets web three. There are plenty of links in the show notes on money, never sleeps, that IE and how to get in touch with us or just drop us an email on info at money now. He sleeps that. I eat finally till next time. Thanks for listening.

39:40 See you it

Pete Townsend Profile Photo

Co-Host

Early-stage startup investor, MD @Techstars Web3, founder of Norio Ventures, mentor, non-executive director, podcaster and bad guitar player.

Eoin Fitzgerald Profile Photo

Co-Host

Fintech investor, podcaster, wannabe VC